I agree with your points here, bnor, and agree that the bears have the advantage for the near and intermediate term. There are a few keys that I'd like to expand on from your analysis too. In reference to the DIA:
-The July-October-December Head-and-Shoulders indicates a downward resistance line into the latter part of the summer (late July, early August. However, that downward resistance is actually part of a pennant feature with some strong support in the 11,800-12,000 area for the same period.
-When you couple the reversal trend support with the previous 2yr upchannel support, they converge right smack on the January bottom, which has at least held thusfar. This leads me to believe that 11,800ish has some massive support to it. A break through 11,800 by any more than 1% in the next month or so portends a fall on the magnitude of that from the 12,700 break to 12,000 in early January. The failure to break through the 50d moving average makes this scenario even more possible as the oscillations are getting tighter and generating more momentum for a breakout. A break through 11,800 will almost certainly take us to 11,000 in short order.
-On a longer time horizion, if we, instead, continue the rocky sideways market until that July/August convergence, we will see an opportunity for either a magnificent reversal or severe correction. That point is where the 2 yr upchannel support and reversal trend resistance converge. After that point, we'll know in which channel we truly belong, and if the head-and-shoulders reversal from the latter half of '07 has truly stuck. In this scenario, I think a bullish bounce out to the 13,000 mark is more likely than a drop through 11,000, but not much more likely, even given that it's the 3rd quarter of the year and traditionally bearish.
-I must admit that even though I'm a perma-bull, the bears have a mighty case that we're in for some trouble. The failure to break and sustain anything above the 50d moving average for the last couple of months coupled with absolutely nothing close to a test of upchannel resistance since breaking it in late December has me worried that we will see 11,000 this year. But, in my bullish opinion, 11,000 just represents massive buying opportunities!